Professor McLoughlin wins 2012 Lifeboat Debate
Over 110 Xavier students voted to answer an unusual
question as seven Xavier professors squared off on
Thursday in the second annual Lifeboat Debate: If you had to rebuild civilization, which single professor would you choose to bring with you, if any? Senior Chris Dobbs and junior Michael Petrany organized the event this year and seven professors participated. The participating professors
consisted of a philosophy professor, a chemistry professor, a mathematics professor, a psychology professor, a political
science professor and a devil's advocate (played by a philosophy professor). The evening concluded after
lively debate with the vote count. Over 110 votes were tallied. Dr. Gottlieb (playing devil's advocate) took third place
with 19 votes, Dr. Chrastil (a history professor) received 32
votes for second place, and Dr. McLoughlin (a chemistry professor) was awarded the first place of an oar after receiving 37 votes. "I thought the devil's advocate would win. And I'm very surprised that chemistry wins anything," McLoughlin said. The event, only in its second year, had an impressive turnout. Dr. Timothy Quinn participated last year and helped organize this year. "I thought it went outstanding.
It was another impressive turnout. The students were enthusiastic, participating faculty were enthusiastic, prepared;they did a great job. [...] If the last two years are any indication, I think that we should be able to continue this for quite a long time, and successfully. It shows you how seriously the students are taking their education," Quinn said. Co-organizer Chris Dobbs verified the success of the evening. "There's no pizza here. If this [event] can legitimately fill up this auditorium, attract [more than one hundred students] and if it's just a talk about the liberal
arts, then I think it shows that the liberal arts are interesting
and valued by Xavier students," Dobbs said. Though serious in its dialogue approach, the evening had its laughs as well, with each professor presenting their own
view of why their subject discipline is superior to the others.
"Philosophy is the most pregnant discipline," Dr. Sweeney
said in the first presentation, "It gave birth to all the others."
Dr. McLoughlin insinuated the limited utility in the other
disciplines and their own education to the audience in a bid
to win votes. "Do you know how to make steel? I do," McLoughlin said. The number of votes that he received proved that he managed to hold his own, despite the fact that he was the only hard science represented at the table.
"Psychology isn't ancient. It's the new kid on the block. We're hip," Dr. Stukenberg said, arguing that his discipline was best. In spite of philosophy professor Dr. Gottlieb claiming that "being hip isn't an argument," Stukenberg still managed to earn a fourth-placed finish. It appears that the advantage that the devil's advocate seemed to hold in last year's debate has been eradicated; both Dobbs and Petrany asserted that the format of this year's debate seemed fair.
Get Top Stories Delivered Weekly
Recent The Xavier University Newswire News Articles
Discuss This Article
GET TOP STORIES DELIVERED WEEKLY
FOLLOW OUR NEWSPAPER
LATEST THE XAVIER UNIVERSITY NEWSWIRE
- Unknown Mortal Orchestra's II
- Bullet to the Head misses its target
- Casual Vacany leaves the reader feeling unfulfilled
- Songs in the Key of... "LOVE" : Players' new show to be annual event
- Respect yourself first
- The future of Xavier
- An inside look into an English professor's academic conferences and conventions
RECENT THE XAVIER UNIVERSITY NEWSWIRE CLASSIFIEDS
OUTSIDE THE LINES
- Moving Resources For Military Families
- Historic Agreement Signed By Red Cross and Armed Forces
- Salonpas® Brand Stands the Test of Time
- Tips to “Yard Your Way” This Spring
- Upgraded Upstate Power Grid Will Deliver a Smarter,...
- A Story To Sing About
- The Gap in Gum Care: Why Caring For Your Teeth’s F...
- Top Tips for Signature Scents and Better-Smelling Laundry
- A Dog Trainer’s Top Tips to Support Pets Through Life S...
- Clear the Air of Indoor Pollutants This Spring
FROM AROUND THE WEB
- Moms Kick Back with Mamaritas
- Youth Apprenticeship Week Spotlights Opportunities
- New Expo Showcases AI Innovation
- Self-Care and Mental Health Tips for Caregivers
- Adventure Awaits: Discover the Playset that Brings...
- Need Auto Glass Repair? Don’t Despair
- Pioneering Fast and Affordable Broadband for the Underserved
- 7 Reasons Renting an RV Should Be On Every Family’s S...
- Don’t Let Diabetes Shortchange Your Golden Years
- No Child is Forgotten By Marine Toys for Tots
COLLEGE PRESS RELEASES
- Guidenar Launches New Career Test for Gen Z
- GotIt! Education Offers MathGPT Free to All State & Community Colleges
- Shoff Promotions Comic Book & Sports Card Show
- Semiconductor Research Corp unveils 2024 Research Call, $13.8M Funding
- Charles River Associates Opens Second Scholarship Cycle, Expands to the UK