Music: Good or Bad?
Can one really determine whether a song or a piece of music is "good" or "bad?" This, over the past three years, has been a constant topic of discussion and a point of contention for myself and plenty of others involved in the music department here on campus. Y e t , in today's world, what we study, known to most as "classical" music is not really prominent nor listened to by a majority of the public. Does that give us a biased view to what is "good" music? Probably. But, this does not mean that we, by any means, are correct in our judgement. I've often thought to myself for lengths of time about this dilemma, though others may disagree with me, I have come to a conclusion. Music, like any other art, is a human creation, an expression of emotion whether it was composed by Beethoven or Mike Posner. Therefore, I would argue that personal experience is the deciding factor. As a kid, I was never forced into listening to classical music on a regular basis or required to play an instrument. It was just something that appealed to me. My brother, on the other hand, sticks to Rap and R&B because it's what speaks to him.
All the different types of music exist because they appeal and speak to someone. Who has the right to judge whether that is good or bad? I think no one. So if you're ever asked if a song is good or bad I would ask that you don't make that distinction but instead decide why you do or do not like it. What makes it appeal to you as an individual? Find that "thing" in the song, whether it's the beat or the melody or a catchy line.That way, when you hear something that doesn't appeal to you, you know why.
I ask my music colleagues to judge a piece of music for its compositional merit. Base that analysis
on compositional techniques rather than just what you hear. Music as a genre deserves more
credit than the superficial words of "good" and "bad." Let it speak and be appreciated. That's why it
exists.
Get Top Stories Delivered Weekly
Recent The Xavier University Newswire News Articles
Discuss This Article
GET TOP STORIES DELIVERED WEEKLY
FOLLOW OUR NEWSPAPER
LATEST THE XAVIER UNIVERSITY NEWSWIRE
- Unknown Mortal Orchestra's II
- Bullet to the Head misses its target
- Casual Vacany leaves the reader feeling unfulfilled
- Songs in the Key of... "LOVE" : Players' new show to be annual event
- Respect yourself first
- The future of Xavier
- An inside look into an English professor's academic conferences and conventions
RECENT THE XAVIER UNIVERSITY NEWSWIRE CLASSIFIEDS
OUTSIDE THE LINES
- Moving Resources For Military Families
- Historic Agreement Signed By Red Cross and Armed Forces
- Salonpas® Brand Stands the Test of Time
- Tips to “Yard Your Way” This Spring
- Upgraded Upstate Power Grid Will Deliver a Smarter,...
- A Story To Sing About
- The Gap in Gum Care: Why Caring For Your Teeth’s F...
- Top Tips for Signature Scents and Better-Smelling Laundry
- A Dog Trainer’s Top Tips to Support Pets Through Life S...
- Clear the Air of Indoor Pollutants This Spring
FROM AROUND THE WEB
- Moms Kick Back with Mamaritas
- Youth Apprenticeship Week Spotlights Opportunities
- New Expo Showcases AI Innovation
- Self-Care and Mental Health Tips for Caregivers
- Adventure Awaits: Discover the Playset that Brings...
- Need Auto Glass Repair? Don’t Despair
- Pioneering Fast and Affordable Broadband for the Underserved
- 7 Reasons Renting an RV Should Be On Every Family’s S...
- Don’t Let Diabetes Shortchange Your Golden Years
- No Child is Forgotten By Marine Toys for Tots
COLLEGE PRESS RELEASES
- Guidenar Launches New Career Test for Gen Z
- GotIt! Education Offers MathGPT Free to All State & Community Colleges
- Shoff Promotions Comic Book & Sports Card Show
- Semiconductor Research Corp unveils 2024 Research Call, $13.8M Funding
- Charles River Associates Opens Second Scholarship Cycle, Expands to the UK